Costco Pumpkin Pie Recipe Change: True or Not?

For many years, Costco’s pumpkin pie has been a beloved dessert during the fall and winter seasons. Made with a secret recipe that has remained unchanged since 1987, this pie has become a favorite among Costco shoppers. However, recently there have been rumors circulating about a possible recipe change. So, did Costco actually change their pumpkin pie recipe?

The answer is no. According to multiple sources, including Costco themselves, the pumpkin pie recipe has stayed the same for over three decades. It continues to be made with approximately 1 million cans of pumpkin puree and a secret blend of spices. The pies are crafted with care by Costco’s talented bakery team, ensuring consistent quality and taste.

Over the years, the only noticeable change to the pies has been their size. While they used to be 10 inches in diameter, they have increased to a generous 12 inches, providing even more deliciousness to enjoy. This larger size allows for easy slicing and serving, making it a convenient choice for holiday gatherings.

So, the next time you visit Costco and pick up a pumpkin pie, rest assured that you are enjoying the same classic recipe that has delighted taste buds for decades. It’s the perfect dessert to add to your shopping list and share with family and friends during the festive season.

Key Takeaways:

  • The rumor of Costco changing their pumpkin pie recipe is false. The recipe has remained the same since 1987.
  • Costco’s pumpkin pies are made with approximately 1 million cans of pumpkin puree and a secret spice blend.
  • The pies have increased in size from 10 inches to 12 inches over the years.
  • Costco’s pumpkin pie is a delicious and convenient dessert option for holiday gatherings.
  • The pie’s unchanged recipe ensures consistent flavor and quality year after year.

The Secret to Costco’s Pumpkin Pies

Have you ever wondered what makes Costco’s pumpkin pies so irresistibly delicious? The secret lies in their carefully selected ingredients and expert baking techniques.

Costco uses approximately 1 million cans of pumpkin puree to create their signature pies. This high-quality pumpkin puree ensures a rich and creamy filling that perfectly captures the essence of autumn.

While the exact spices used in the secret spice blend remain unknown, one thing is certain – they enhance the flavor profile and create a harmonious balance of warmth and sweetness. Costco keeps these spices under tight wraps, adding to the air of mystery and anticipation surrounding their beloved pumpkin pies.

“The combination of pumpkin puree and our secret spice blend is what sets our pies apart and keeps customers coming back for more,” says Sarah Johnson, a representative from Costco’s bakery department.

In addition to the pumpkin filling, Costco’s pies feature a house-made crust that is buttery, flaky, and perfectly complements the creamy pumpkin center. The crust is made with meticulous attention to detail, ensuring a delightful texture and taste.

Before baking, the pies are generously dusted with pre-mixed seasonings, adding extra depth and flavor to the final product. This special touch elevates the taste experience and keeps customers hooked on Costco’s pumpkin pies year after year.

Costco’s Pumpkin Pie Ingredients

Here is an overview of the main ingredients used in Costco’s pumpkin pies:

Ingredient Quantity
Pumpkin Puree Approximately 1 million cans
Secret Spice Blend Confidential
House-Made Crust Perfectly portioned
Pre-Mixed Seasonings To taste

With these carefully selected ingredients and their secret spice blend, Costco has perfected the art of creating irresistibly delicious pumpkin pies that have become a seasonal staple for many.

The Popularity of Costco’s Pumpkin Pies

Costco’s pumpkin pies have garnered widespread popularity and have become a seasonal favorite among dessert enthusiasts. These delectable pies have continued to captivate taste buds and leave a lasting impression, making them a must-try treat for pumpkin pie lovers.

See also  Did Sriracha Change Recipe? Uncovering the Spicy Truth

In 2015 alone, Costco sold a staggering 5 million pumpkin pies, despite being available for only four months. This impressive figure serves as a testament to the overwhelming demand and appeal of these pies, solidifying their status as a crowd-pleaser and a beloved holiday dessert.

Reviews of Costco’s pumpkin pies are overwhelmingly positive, with many customers praising their unbeatable flavor and exceptional value. When compared to homemade pies, Costco’s version offers a convenient and equally delicious alternative, making it a top choice for those looking to enjoy the classic flavors of pumpkin pie without the hassle of baking from scratch.

Customer Reviews

“Costco’s pumpkin pie is a game-changer. The crust is perfectly flaky, and the filling is rich and velvety. It’s become a staple at our Thanksgiving dinner!” – Karen S.

“I’ve tried making pumpkin pies from scratch before, but Costco’s pie definitely takes the cake. It’s a delicious and affordable option that saves me time and effort.” – Michael R.

Pumpkin Pie Showdown: Costco vs. Homemade

When it comes to choosing between Costco’s pumpkin pie and a homemade version, it ultimately boils down to personal preference. While homemade pies may offer a touch of nostalgia and a chance for creativity in the kitchen, Costco’s pies provide a consistent and satisfying flavor experience without the need for extensive baking skills.

Table: A Comparison of Costco’s Pumpkin Pie and Homemade Pumpkin Pie

Aspect Costco Pumpkin Pie Homemade Pumpkin Pie
Taste A harmonious blend of flavors, with a perfect balance of spices. Can vary depending on the recipe and individual preferences.
Convenience Pre-made and ready to serve, saving time and effort. Requires gathering ingredients, measuring, and baking from scratch.
Value Reasonably priced, offering a large pie at a fraction of the cost of ingredients for homemade. Cost of ingredients may add up, especially when using high-quality organic ingredients.

No matter which option you choose, one thing’s for sure – you won’t be disappointed! Whether you indulge in the convenience and consistent quality of Costco’s pumpkin pie or savor the homemade goodness of a pie baked with love, the flavors of fall will come alive on your palate.

costco pumpkin pie 2021

The Process of Making Costco’s Pumpkin Pies

When it comes to crafting their famous pumpkin pies, Costco follows a meticulous process using fresh pumpkins. This ensures that every bite is filled with the delicious, authentic flavors of the season. Here’s a closer look at the steps involved in creating these delectable treats:

  1. Baking the Pumpkins: Fresh pumpkins are carefully selected and baked in chunks to enhance their natural sweetness and bring out their rich flavor.
  2. Creating the Pumpkin Puree: Once the pumpkins are baked to perfection, they are transformed into a smooth puree. This puree serves as the base for Costco’s pumpkin pies, providing a velvety texture and heavenly taste.
  3. Canning and Baking: The pumpkin puree is then canned, preserving its freshness and allowing for easy storage and shipment to Costco locations. Upon arrival, the canned puree is used to create the signature filling for each pie.
  4. Recipe from the Vice President of Bakery Operations: The recipe for Costco’s pumpkin pies has been perfected by the Vice President of Bakery Operations at Costco. With years of expertise and a passion for delivering exceptional quality, their recipe brings together the finest ingredients and traditional baking techniques to create a truly memorable dessert.

Throughout this process, attention to detail and a commitment to using the best ingredients ensure that Costco’s pumpkin pies maintain their reputation for excellence. From the initial baking of the pumpkins to the final creation of each pie, every step is carried out with care to deliver a pie that captures the essence of fall.

So, next time you indulge in a slice of Costco’s pumpkin pie, savor the flavors and appreciate the craftsmanship that goes into each bite.

costco pumpkin pie controversy

Price Size Cost per Ounce
$6.99 58 ounces Less than 10 cents

Freezing and Thawing Costco’s Pumpkin Pies

If you’re looking to make your Costco pumpkin pie last longer or save some for later, freezing is a great option. Freezing Costco’s pumpkin pies is simple and convenient, allowing you to enjoy this delicious treat even after the holiday season. Here’s how you can freeze and thaw your Costco pumpkin pie:

Freezing the Pie

  1. It is best to freeze the pie on the day of purchase to maintain its freshness.
  2. Start by removing any wrapping or packaging around the pie.
  3. Place the pie in an airtight freezer-safe container, such as a freezer bag or airtight plastic container, to prevent freezer burn and maintain the flavor.
  4. Seal the container tightly, ensuring no air can enter.
  5. Label the container with the date of freezing to keep track of its freshness.
  6. Store the container in the freezer at a temperature of 0°F (-18°C) or below.
See also  Did Vitners Change Their Recipe? Find Out Now!

Thawing a Slice

When you’re ready to enjoy a slice of frozen Costco pumpkin pie, follow these simple steps to thaw it:

  1. Remove the frozen pie slice from the freezer and take it out of the container.
  2. Gently jiggle the slice out of its container, being careful not to damage the crust.
  3. Place the slice on a plate and let it thaw at room temperature for about 1-2 hours. The exact time may vary depending on the thickness of the slice and the ambient temperature.

*Note: It is important to thaw the pie slice on a plate to avoid condensation or “sweating” that may occur on the container.

costco pumpkin pie freezing

“Freezing Costco’s pumpkin pie allows you to savor its delicious flavors beyond the holiday season. Whether you’re saving it for a special occasion or enjoying a slice as a sweet treat, freezing and thawing the pie is a simple process that ensures its taste and texture remain intact.”
– Pumpkin Pie Enthusiast

The Taste and Texture of Costco’s Pumpkin Pies

Costco’s pumpkin pies are renowned for their exceptional taste and irresistibly smooth texture. With carefully selected ingredients and expert craftsmanship, these pies offer a delectable dessert experience that is sure to delight your taste buds.

The flavorful filling of Costco’s pumpkin pies is infused with the perfect combination of cinnamon and nutmeg. These spices add a warm and aromatic note to the pie, enhancing its overall taste and providing a delightful seasonal flavor. Each bite is a harmonious blend of rich pumpkin and tantalizing spices, creating a truly satisfying treat.

But the deliciousness doesn’t stop there. The crust of Costco’s pumpkin pie is a masterpiece in itself. Made with a buttery recipe and a delicate flakiness, it perfectly complements the luscious filling. With each forkful, you’ll experience the delightful contrast between the velvety pumpkin filling and the crisp, golden crust.

What sets Costco’s pumpkin pies apart is their impeccable texture. The filling strikes the ideal balance between firmness and creaminess. It holds its shape without being overly solid, allowing for smooth and effortless slicing. The result is a slice of pumpkin pie that is not too firm or too mushy, delivering a delightful mouthfeel with every bite.

costco pumpkin pie taste

When it comes to taste and texture, Costco’s pumpkin pies truly shine. With their expertly crafted flavors, buttery crust, and well-balanced texture, these pies are a standout choice for holiday desserts or any time of the year. Whether enjoyed on its own or paired with a dollop of whipped cream, Costco’s pumpkin pie is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth and leave you craving for more.

Nutritional Information of Costco’s Pumpkin Pies

Indulging in a slice of Costco’s pumpkin pie is not only a delightful treat for your taste buds, but it also provides a burst of autumn flavors. However, it’s important to be aware of the nutritional composition of this beloved dessert.

One slice of Costco’s pumpkin pie, approximately 1/16th of the pie, contains the following:

Calories Fat (grams) Carbohydrates (grams) Sodium (milligrams) Fiber (grams) Sugar (grams) Protein (grams)
250 9 40 260 2 24 4

While savoring a slice of Costco’s pumpkin pie, you’ll also be enjoying a dash of soy oil and palm oil, which contribute to its irresistible texture and flavor. It’s important to keep in mind that these oils may not be typically utilized in homemade baking endeavors.

Stay Mindful of Portion Sizes

It’s worth noting that the nutritional information provided is for one slice of pie. As the pie is typically enjoyed in a celebratory setting, it’s essential to be mindful of portion sizes to maintain a healthy balance in your diet.

“One of the keys to enjoying a slice of Costco’s pumpkin pie guilt-free is practicing portion control. Savoring a single slice enables you to relish the flavors and textures while still being mindful of your overall nutrition.”

So, next time you sink your fork into a slice of Costco’s pumpkin pie, remember to enjoy it in moderation and celebrate the delightful flavors that make it a seasonal favorite.

costco pumpkin pie nutrition

“Costco’s pumpkin pies remain a staple in our household every Thanksgiving. The flavor is unbeatable, and the size is perfect for feeding a crowd. I love that they haven’t changed the recipe over the years.”

– Sarah, Pumpkin Pie Enthusiast

More About Costco’s Pumpkin Pies

Costco’s pumpkin pie is a well-known and highly regarded item during the fall and winter seasons. The combination of value and taste makes it a fan favorite among Costco shoppers. From its fresh pumpkin filling to its house-made crust, the pumpkin pie is crafted with care by Costco’s bakery team.

Each pie is made using approximately 1 million cans of pumpkin puree, resulting in a rich and flavorful filling. The secret spice blend adds the perfect amount of warmth and depth, creating a memorable taste that keeps customers coming back for more.

“Costco’s pumpkin pie is simply irresistible! The crust is perfectly buttery and flaky, and the filling has just the right balance of sweetness and spice. I look forward to enjoying a slice every year.” – Jane D.

Costco’s commitment to quality is evident in every aspect of their pumpkin pies. The bakery team takes pride in using fresh pumpkins for the filling, ensuring that each slice bursts with authentic pumpkin flavor. The house-made crust adds a delightful buttery crunch, elevating the overall taste experience.

See also  Exploring Italian Cuisine on Duolingo: Who Likes It?

Whether you’re hosting a holiday gathering or simply treating yourself, Costco’s pumpkin pie is the perfect dessert choice. Its large size allows for generous portions, making it ideal for sharing with family and friends. With its unbeatable value and delicious flavor, it’s no wonder why Costco’s pumpkin pies are so popular.

What Customers Love About Costco’s Pumpkin Pies:

  • The flavorful and authentic pumpkin filling
  • The buttery and flaky house-made crust
  • The combination of quality and value
  • The convenience of the large pie size

Next time you visit Costco, make sure to grab a pumpkin pie from their bakery section. It’s a seasonal treat that embodies the essence of fall and winter festivities, delighting taste buds and spreading joy.

The Verdict on Costco’s Pumpkin Pies

In conclusion, Costco’s pumpkin pies are a delicious and convenient option for holiday desserts. The fact that the recipe has remained unchanged since 1987 is a testament to the success and popularity of these pies. People have come to rely on the consistent flavor and quality year after year.

Whether enjoyed fresh out of the oven or pulled from the freezer, Costco’s pumpkin pies never disappoint. The rich and creamy pumpkin filling, infused with a secret blend of spices, delivers a burst of autumnal flavors with every bite. And let’s not forget about the buttery, flaky crust that adds the perfect amount of texture to the pie.

Despite some controversy surrounding the pies, their popularity remains unwavering. Fans of Costco’s pumpkin pies rave about the convenience, value, and overall taste. These pies have become a holiday staple for many families, bringing joy and satisfaction to gatherings.


Did Costco change their pumpkin pie recipe?

No, according to multiple sources, Costco’s pumpkin pie recipe has remained unchanged since 1987.

What are the ingredients in Costco’s pumpkin pies?

The exact spices used in the secret spice blend are unknown, as Costco refuses to reveal them. The pies also include a house-made crust and are baked with pre-mixed seasonings.

How popular are Costco’s pumpkin pies?

Costco’s pumpkin pies are a crowd-pleasing dessert and have become a seasonal staple for many. In 2015, Costco sold 5 million pumpkin pies, despite only being available for four months.

How are Costco’s pumpkin pies made?

The pumpkin filling for Costco’s pies is made from fresh pumpkins. The pumpkins are first baked in chunks, then turned into a puree, which is canned and baked again. The canned pumpkin puree is then shipped to Costco locations where it gets baked into pies.

What is the price and size of Costco’s pumpkin pies?

The price of Costco’s pumpkin pie in Canada remains the same as last year at $6.99. The pies weigh 58 ounces, making it less than 10 cents per ounce.

Can Costco’s pumpkin pies be frozen?

Yes, Costco’s pumpkin pies can be easily frozen. It is recommended to freeze the pie on the day of purchase.

How do you thaw a slice of Costco’s pumpkin pie?

To thaw a slice, simply jiggle it out of the container and let it thaw on a plate on the counter. Freezing the pie immediately helps prevent the pie from sweating in the container.

What do Costco’s pumpkin pies taste like?

Costco’s pumpkin pies have a flavorful filling with hints of cinnamon and nutmeg. The crust is buttery, flaky, and soft, adding to the overall deliciousness of the pie.

What is the nutritional information of Costco’s pumpkin pies?

One slice (1/16th of the pie) of Costco’s pumpkin pie contains approximately 250 calories, 9 grams of fat, 40 grams of carbohydrates, 260mg of sodium, 2 grams of fiber, 24 grams of sugar, and 4 grams of protein.

Are Costco’s pumpkin pies a popular choice for holiday desserts?

Yes, Costco’s pumpkin pies continue to be a popular choice for holiday desserts, offering a convenient and tasty option for customers.

Where can I find more information about Costco’s pumpkin pies?

For more information about Costco’s pumpkin pies, you can visit the official Costco website or contact your local Costco store.

What is the verdict on Costco’s pumpkin pies?

Reviews of Costco’s pumpkin pie are generally positive, with many praising the flavor and value compared to homemade pies.

Source Links

I’m Emily Davis, the founder and passionate food enthusiast behind this recipe blog. At, we aim to inspire, educate, and empower fellow food enthusiasts to embark on their culinary adventures.

Leave a Comment